REGISTER
 

Tom's training log...

12345678910 ... 488489490 ... 865866867868869870871872873874875

martinbIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:36 
Avatar
Grass fed
Member 1147, 7710 posts
SQ 220, BP 185, DL 272.5
677.5 kgs @ 113kgs UnEq
Don't you think a lot of the positioning you can achieve at the bottom of a squat is down to hip mobility?

I'm a mong and a horrible squatter, and thought I would forever be that way, but doing some stretches Shane posted on another thread from a crossfit guy, and all of a sudden I can get in to a similar position to the woman in that photo

although I would imagine your hip mobility would already be really good?
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:41 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
martinb said:Don't you think a lot of the positioning you can achieve at the bottom of a squat is down to hip mobility?

I'm a mong and a horrible squatter, and thought I would forever be that way, but doing some stretches Shane posted on another thread from a crossfit guy, and all of a sudden I can get in to a similar position to the woman in that photo

although I would imagine your hip mobility would already be really good?


look how far forward her knees are than her toes. Further than mine are anyway. its much easier to be sat upright when your knees are forward. how far forward is dependant on leg length and how much you can push your knees to the side. if you sit back you need a f**king lot of arch in your back to have your upper torso that upright.
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:42 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
unless you have tiny legs. its all about how close your hips are to the vertical plane of the bar. the closer you can get them, the more upright you will be. How you get them closer is dependant on a lot of things...
martinbIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:46 
Avatar
Grass fed
Member 1147, 7710 posts
SQ 220, BP 185, DL 272.5
677.5 kgs @ 113kgs UnEq
Tom_Martin said:unless you have tiny legs. its all about how close your hips are to the vertical plane of the bar. the closer you can get them, the more upright you will be. How you get them closer is dependant on a lot of things...


yes, I never got my hips anywhere near that plane previously, I thought it was a limb length thing, but more hip mobility and I can get much closer
FazcIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:50 
Avatar
Sports an extremely muscular arse.
Member 38, 6253 posts
Tom_Martin said:
hey! never mind the getting up bit, i'm still working on getting down! with a lot of calf stretching and a light enough weight i can, but my quads really will not allow me to lower into that position with a heavy enough weight.
They give up and then i tip forwards to put tension on my hamstrings and then i hold that position using...my hamstrings. I know you don't believe me though!


I do believe you Tom!

The comment I made about femur length might be sort of what I'm getting at. I'm not entirely sure it will be physically possible to squat how you want, with heavy weight and with your femurs.

You tip forward because your femurs are crazy long. You've stretched your calves loads and there's only so far your knees can go forward. After that it's almost inevitable that your hips are going to have to push back. You've already experienced first hand how some hip-drive has benefited you, further strengthening in that area might not always make for a prettier squat but probably will make for a smoother one.

Thinking about it in that way, we're not saying massively different things. When your femurs are at parallel the body needs to find some way to cope with that position. Your knees will inevitably be somewhat forward and your hips inevitably somewhat back. Your focus is on strengthening the knees to allow you to stay more upright, mine is on strengthening the hips for drive through. You think a more exaggerated knee dominant squat will be better, I say you'll struggle with that. I say a more exaggerated hip dominant squat is more realistic and you say you don't want to do that.

(That's starting to sound like a Paula Abdul song, so I'll stop that now)

I think we've probably already found the best answer, given your results in the past few weeks. Stick to your current squat form and keep strengthening the Fronts/Hacks and GMs.
FazcIcon...14-08-2012 @ 14:58 
Avatar
Sports an extremely muscular arse.
Member 38, 6253 posts
I found this picture while googling 'olympic squat bottom position' and I think it's relevant here!

http://img.breakingmuscle.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/f...
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 15:07 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
the hip drive is beneficial regardless of squat style....glutes pushing forwards, great I'm on board. what i should have said from the start though, is I CAN push my knees further forwards into that position, it is necessary when i front squat to push them further forwards and i am coping with the weights i front squat like that....but the weights i back squat i am just too weak to push my knees further forwards....it's a work in progress.


If I was squatting in a powerlifting comp, it would be exactly as i am now. If I was trying to catch a clean, it would not....
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 15:08 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
Fazc said:I found this picture while googling 'olympic squat bottom position' and I think it's relevant here!

http://img.breakingmuscle.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/f...

I think this effectively closes the discussion!
DANGERUSSIcon...14-08-2012 @ 15:58 
Avatar
Member 1687, 113 posts
SQ 240, BP 170, DL 265
675.0 kgs @ 100kgs Eq
Tom_Martin said:also the weight coming foawards is clearly due to me leaning forwards which is anything but putting the weight on my quads.

keeping more upright on the descent allows me to keep the weight over my feet as seen in front squat. I still maintain that when I descend with a more upright back, my quads are very obviously what give up first (i feel it happening because....i am the one squatting....)


That's a good pic of the Girl in the hole (no jokes). If you could get the bar in that position (directly over mid foot) rather than all the way out infront of your toes.

In would be good to compare a full frontal view (still no jokes) to compare how open the hips are or how far the knees are pushed out.

Do you have a video of your 'leaning forward' squat i.e not trying to stay upright?
DANGERUSSIcon...14-08-2012 @ 16:12 
Avatar
Member 1687, 113 posts
SQ 240, BP 170, DL 265
675.0 kgs @ 100kgs Eq
Tom_Martin said:Case in point, this is my refference for squat technique



He does it a little narrower than me, and there's no way I can come close to that with a low bar either, but we're not all Alexey Sorokin!


THis is that example video you posted previously
Break at the hips, and knees are forced out hard. Then on the way backup up knees stay out.

I noticed going back to your vids of you first attempting this tech (Your 190kg on 02-04-2012).... You started your decent well but on the way up your knees bow in. I think this causes the hips to shoot back???

Apparantly according to mystical sources, if you cant keep your knees forced out then that is a hip/glute weakness from that position and the quads are taking over the lift at this point.

This guy you posted about does not have the slightes of bowing of knees. If you could get that bit right I think your hip line would be much better and you would stay more upright.
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 17:07 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
DANGERUSS said:
THis is that example video you posted previously
Break at the hips, and knees are forced out hard. Then on the way backup up knees stay out.
I noticed going back to your vids of you first attempting this tech (Your 190kg on 02-04-2012).... You started your decent well but on the way up your knees bow in. I think this causes the hips to shoot back???
Apparantly according to mystical sources, if you cant keep your knees forced out then that is a hip/glute weakness from that position and the quads are taking over the lift at this point.
This guy you posted about does not have the slightes of bowing of knees. If you could get that bit right I think your hip line would be much better and you would stay more upright.


The knees out thing is still a big focus...mine at the moment are more likely to shoot back than inwards though but without a video from the front you will never know

also this tech is great but he is always bare minimum on depth which isn't what i am going for anymore, and changes things.
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 17:09 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
he is a lot shorter than me yet his ass is considerably further from the floor than mine is, we're not comparing the same thing anymore...
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 17:18 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
I guess i have moved the goal posts since then, not really fair on you lot lol but i'm always changing my mind about what i want, i just go after it until its not fun anymore then pick another goal, right or wrong i don't give a s**t, i train because i enjoy it.

speaking of,

back and bis

seated row - full stack x 10,10,10
db row- 45kg x 10,10,10
shrugs - 220kg x 5,5,5

standin curls

40kg x 8
50kg x 8
40kg x 10,10,10

cable curls - stupid triple drop set.


most enjoyable Happy

arms pumped to 17.5" afterwards, not seen those numbers since before the diet Happy
JohnGymIcon...14-08-2012 @ 20:57 
Avatar
Hamstrings feel activated.
Member 1107, 6964 posts
SQ 220, BP 152.5, DL 252.5
625.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
12.70s electronically timed. Beat that biatch.
Tom_MartinIcon...14-08-2012 @ 22:01 
Avatar
No one believed him anyway.
Member 958, 11411 posts
SQ 410, BP 215, DL 425
1050.0 kgs @ 100kgs UnEq
JohnGym said:12.70s electronically timed. Beat that biatch.


tell me when the next one is, i'm there! did they drug test you?

12345678910 ... 488489490 ... 865866867868869870871872873874875

© Sugden Barbell 2026 Privacy - Terms & Conditions