| Fazc | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 15:54 | |
Sports an extremely muscular arse. Member 38, 6253 posts | AdamC said:I have respect for any lifter that steps onto the platform and gives it their all, whether that's in just a belt, single ply or multiply. This is the crux of it as far as I'm concerned. This thread is a microcosm for this larger debate all across the net. You don't get equipped lifters calling raw lifters less valid competitors competing in a less valid sport. But if you're raw, it seems perfectly acceptable to make those comments toward equipped lifters. Frankly that needs to stop, it's not just discussion at that point. | ||
| MaxCooper | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 15:57 | |
1000 post points - NAILED Member 2026, 1344 posts SQ 195, BP 152.5, DL 235582.5 kgs @ 94kgs UnEq | Steve said: People like to know who's best - that's part of the attraction of competitive sports however why can it not be aknowledged that they are the strongest person in the world EQUIPPED and the other is the strongest UNEQUIPPED thats like quibbling about the olympics saying bolt isnt the fastest man cos the didnt win the 800m and marathons, we say hes the fastest man OVER 100M/200M | ||
| AdamC | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 15:58 | |
Member 1519, 1476 posts SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq | Steve said: People like to know who's best - that's part of the attraction of competitive sports the best is the person who lifts the most on the platform that day | ||
| JH | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:01 | |
Member 1739, 1266 posts SQ 365, BP 245, DL 332.5942.5 kgs @ 105kgs Eq | AdamC said: the best is the person who lifts the most on the platform that day Agreed. | ||
| IainKendrick | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:03 | |
some nice relaxing jazz. Member 77, 12599 posts SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq | Post Edited: 15.08.2012 @ 16:04 PM by IainKendrick Fazc said: This is the crux of it as far as I'm concerned. This thread is a microcosm for this larger debate all across the net. You don't get equipped lifters calling raw lifters less valid competitors competing in a less valid sport. But if you're raw, it seems perfectly acceptable to make those comments toward equipped lifters. Frankly that needs to stop, it's not just discussion at that point. Actually I have heard much many times, and if people think that raw lifting is q lesser sport then I am fine with that. I disagree but have no pr oblem with people wanting to so. Why dose style need to ne beyond reproach? Ohh and equipped lifters are not less valid competitors. Clearly equipped lifting currently has the Lyon share of the best and strongest competitors! | ||
| deleted2_20210523 | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:04 | |
Member 2606, 11453 posts SQ 170, BP 117.5, DL 215502.5 kgs @ 91.6kgs UnEq | deleted | ||
| Steve | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:25 | |
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam Member 255, 3732 posts | AdamC said: the best is the person who lifts the most on the platform that day So equipped lifters are better than unequipped? | ||
| Steve | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:27 | |
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam Member 255, 3732 posts | Fazc said: This is the crux of it as far as I'm concerned. This thread is a microcosm for this larger debate all across the net. You don't get equipped lifters calling raw lifters less valid competitors competing in a less valid sport. But if you're raw, it seems perfectly acceptable to make those comments toward equipped lifters. Frankly that needs to stop, it's not just discussion at that point. There are many equipped lifters claiming that because they lift the most they must be the strongest (the same also applies to untested). By claiming to be the strongest they are if effect putting down the efforts of the unequipped lifter. | ||
| deleted2_20210523 | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:35 | |
Member 2606, 11453 posts SQ 170, BP 117.5, DL 215502.5 kgs @ 91.6kgs UnEq | deleted | ||
| AdamC | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:36 | |
Member 1519, 1476 posts SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq | Steve said: So equipped lifters are better than unequipped? I never said that Very rarely do both unequipped and equipped lifters compete in the same flight | ||
| AdamC | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:39 | |
Member 1519, 1476 posts SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq | kirkynick said: Exactly, they are different sports, but using the same basic name of powerlifting. When I asked him, it was more of asking why are Russian lifters so good, rather than asking him to compare, but he seemed to take is as a comparison. I can see the skill involved in equipped powerlifting, and I often watch the IPF Worlds But, personally for me, equipment was one of the reasons I decided not to compete in powerlifting. My guess is he's probably he's had so many people slagging off his lifters, saying they aren't as good as this lifter or that lifter that he instantly just goes straight on the defense | ||
| deleted2_20210523 | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:42 | |
Member 2606, 11453 posts SQ 170, BP 117.5, DL 215502.5 kgs @ 91.6kgs UnEq | deleted | ||
| Fazc | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 16:53 | |
Sports an extremely muscular arse. Member 38, 6253 posts | Steve said: There are many equipped lifters claiming that because they lift the most they must be the strongest (the same also applies to untested). By claiming to be the strongest they are if effect putting down the efforts of the unequipped lifter. Yeah, putting other people down like that is not cool. By taking part in that all you're doing is encouraging that cycle. In this thread in particular it came from the raw lifters. So was there really a need to start with that s**t here, I'd say probably not. Recognise them for what they are, different things. Like I said at the beginning, just do your thang and be happy with it. | ||
| IainKendrick | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 17:07 | |
some nice relaxing jazz. Member 77, 12599 posts SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq | Fazc said: Recognise them for what they are, different things. Like I said at the beginning, just do your thang and be happy with it. I fully agree. I am sorry if I have caused offense. It was/is not my intenion to bellitle individuals. Although I am well aware that it is a conmtencious issue. Merely stating my views on a comparison of both styles. I would not post in certain logs, watch IPF worlds, or have a signed T-shirt from Andy Bolton etc etc etc if I thought equipped lifting was some terrible activity! | ||
| AdamC | ... | 15-08-2012 @ 17:18 | |
Member 1519, 1476 posts SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq | I think what people forget is that powerlifting needs both raw and equipped lifters loosing one or the other would seriously deplete the amount of people competing in powerlifting and that cant be a good thing at all! | ||