REGISTER
 

Equipped- how much extra does it give?

1234567891011

MaxCooperIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:31 
Avatar
1000 post points - NAILED
Member 2026, 1344 posts
SQ 195, BP 152.5, DL 235
582.5 kgs @ 94kgs UnEq
Post Edited: 15.08.2012 @ 15:34 PM by MaxCooper
tbh id be pissed off if someone rang me and questioned the validity of my lifts and those ive coached (ah the many people ive coached lol) plus you rang and asked about his gyms totals, which is a gym well known to prety much only do multi ply, hes obviously going to assume your talking multi ply unless your withholding info like Rolex did and are going to bring up at a later date you specified multi vs Russian Raw at the time

HOWEVER with the topic of Multi vs Single ply being brought up im out cos that to me is the most rediculous arguement int he world, other than my preference of multi play i do quite enjoy raw, just not as much BUT single vs multi is bull...
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:33 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Fazc said:
Because when discussing equipped powerlifting it is inevitably, just like it has been in this thread, the raw lifters who are the ones who start throwing around the "raw is the future of powerlifting" and as you've said "less valid" crap. It's an opprobriation of the sport that many of us fully enjoy and devote a lot of time to.
It's old and tired.


It's my opinion on the sport, and I am happy to stand by them. It may get 'old and tired' to some, but then I feel the same way about the defence of equipment use lol The IPF classic hasn't come about through nobody careing about this stuff.

I am passionate about the sport same as yourself. Even if we disagree about it's future direction. If they subject comes up I love to dicuss it!
AdamCIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:40 
Avatar
Member 1519, 1476 posts
SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320
900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq
Its amusing how a large majority (but not all)of raw lifters think they are better and superior to equipped lifters because they choose not to use equipment, you very rarely see equipped lifters slagging off or putting down raw lifters or their accomplishments!

This whole bo***cks of some raw lifters saying 'such and such cant actually squat 1000lbs because he used a suit and wraps' is just petty bulls**t, of course that lifter can squat that amount, the suit and wraps haven't taken the weight off the bar, saying that the kit is doing % or the lift for them is crap

if you have 2 lifters who both can squat 750lbs raw
lifter a competes raw
lifter b competes in kit and can squat 1000lbs in kit
if you gave the lifter a the same suit and wraps as lifter b do you think he'll squat 1000lbs too? no chances are he wouldn't even be strong enough to unrack it!

I have respect for any lifter that steps onto the platform and gives it their all, whether that's in just a belt, single ply or multiply.

There are competitions that cater for all lifters, so why cant raw lifters just get on with the comps they want to do while equipped lifters can do the comps they want to do

at the end of the day powerlifting is about shifting huge weights, it doesn't matter what people are wearing while they do it

Strong men (with the exception of bench shirts) use just as much kit as powerlifters so, they also use double and triple ply elbow and knee wraps, yet you don't see people saying Terry or Loz are less valid strongman because they used kit!!
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:42 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
AdamC said:Its amusing how a large majority (but not all)of raw lifters think they are better and superior to equipped lifters because they choose not to use equipment, you very rarely see equipped lifters slagging off or putting down raw lifters or their accomplishments!

This whole bo***cks of some raw lifters saying 'such and such cant actually squat 1000lbs because he used a suit and wraps' is just petty bulls**t, of course that lifter can squat that amount, the suit and wraps haven't taken the weight off the bar, saying that the kit is doing % or the lift for them is crap
used kit!!


1) I don't think of myself as superior. However in my eyes powerlifting is a more valid strength sport without gear.

2) No the lifter cannot squat that weight without the support and aid of his gear. The gear is doing a % of the work. Otherwise why wera gear? lol
AdamCIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:46 
Avatar
Member 1519, 1476 posts
SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320
900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq
IainKendrick said:
1) I don't think of myself as superior. However in my eyes powerlifting is a more valid strength sport without gear.


You consider raw lifters to be more valid lifters then equipped, I'd say there's a hint of feeling superior in there!
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:46 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
The unfortunate side effect of this is that to most people outside the sport powerlifting has become a complete joke. It used to mean something if you became powerlifting World Champion or set powerlifting records records. Nowadays it seems like there's a record or championship available for almost everyone.

With powerlifting in the mess it is now there will almost certainly never be another Ed Coan. Not because it's impossible for anybody to ever be thaat goodd, but because they would just be anotherr lifterr amonngst the dozens of World Champions
FazcIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:46 
Avatar
Sports an extremely muscular arse.
Member 38, 6253 posts
Post Edited: 15.08.2012 @ 15:47 PM by Fazc
IainKendrick said:It may get 'old and tired' to some, but then I feel the same way about the defence of equipment use lol


I don't go into raw threads and proclaim they should all don suits and shirts and go equipped because raw is somehow a 'lesser' version of the sport. In fact I competed raw for 5 years and you know what? I didn't give a crap what anyone around me was doing and I certainly wouldn't go into a debate dealing specifically with equipment and proclaim that what they were doing is somehow less valid than what I was.

Discussion is fine, but this is more than that. As you've noted there are raw comps popping up and there are raw divisions in feds, so like I said in my first post in this thread...just do your thang. If you want to debate then that's fine but comments like what we've had here are more than discussion and it's about time that was pointed out. It's not just discussion, it's condemning an entire branch of the sport to something 'less' because it doesn't agree with you. That's not just discussion.
AdamCIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:49 
Avatar
Member 1519, 1476 posts
SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320
900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq
Steve said:The unfortunate side effect of this is that to most people outside the sport powerlifting has become a complete joke. It used to mean something if you became powerlifting World Champion or set powerlifting records records. Nowadays it seems like there's a record or championship available for almost everyone.

With powerlifting in the mess it is now there will almost certainly never be another Ed Coan. Not because it's impossible for anybody to ever be thaat goodd, but because they would just be anotherr lifterr amonngst the dozens of World Champions


That isn't a problem caused by people using kit, its a problem caused by there being too many federations!

Theres 5 that i can think of in the uk alone
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:49 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
AdamC said:
You consider raw lifters to be more valid lifters then equipped, I'd say there's a hint of feeling superior in there!


I said I do not feel superior. However I do feel unequipped/classic is superior to equipped as I want the sport to be about whom can lift the most on the day not whom can lift the most wearing lots of supportive equipment.
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:49 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
AdamC said:
if you have 2 lifters who both can squat 750lbs raw
lifter a competes raw
lifter b competes in kit and can squat 1000lbs in kit
if you gave the lifter a the same suit and wraps as lifter b do you think he'll squat 1000lbs too? no chances are he wouldn't even be strong enough to unrack it!



If lifter a lifts 800lbs unequipped, whilst lifter b lifts just 700lbs unequipped, but squats 1000lbs equipped, who is the stronger person? I can't see how it can possibly be lifter b.
AdamCIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:51 
Avatar
Member 1519, 1476 posts
SQ 320, BP 260, DL 320
900.0 kgs @ 117kgs Eq
Steve said:
If lifter a lifts 800lbs unequipped, whilst lifter b lifts just 700lbs unequipped, but squats 1000lbs equipped, who is the stronger person? I can't see how it can possibly be lifter b.


Who cares?

they are both strong, one lifter has chosen to develop his raw strength, and the other his equipped strengths
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:52 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
AdamC said:
That isn't a problem caused by people using kit, its a problem caused by there being too many federations!
Theres 5 that i can think of in the uk alone


Five federations with equipped and unequipped equals 10 lots of championships and records. Equipped/unequipped lifting has made the problem twice as bad.
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:52 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Fazc said:
It's not just discussion, it's condemning an entire branch of the sport to something 'less' because it doesn't agree with you. That's not just discussion.


It's my opinion and has been part of this dicussion. I still actually like equipped powerlifting, just think classic is better! Is it really bad to state this?
MaxCooperIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:53 
Avatar
1000 post points - NAILED
Member 2026, 1344 posts
SQ 195, BP 152.5, DL 235
582.5 kgs @ 94kgs UnEq
Adam id abandon the arguement, theres no reasoning with people who take the stance only one thing can be correct even if you say they are both correct...
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 15:54 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
AdamC said:
Who cares?
they are both strong, one lifter has chosen to develop his raw strength, and the other his equipped strengths


People like to know who's best - that's part of the attraction of competitive sports

1234567891011

© Sugden Barbell 2026 Privacy - Terms & Conditions