REGISTER
 

Equipped- how much extra does it give?

1234567891011

IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:27 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
force10 said:Some great points been raised, im just wondering how strong equipped lifter realy are without tne equipment.

.


Strong. As the best guys are in any fed style of powerlifting. However the strongest dosn't always win. Guy whose strong and gets more out of the gear will. This, to me, is the problem with equipped lifting.
MaxCooperIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:29 
Avatar
1000 post points - NAILED
Member 2026, 1344 posts
SQ 195, BP 152.5, DL 235
582.5 kgs @ 94kgs UnEq
Post Edited: 15.08.2012 @ 13:30 PM by MaxCooper
except people who are stong equipped arent automatically weak raw, infact those who are the stongest in the world EQ. are usually the same guys whod be the stongest uneq.
For example Donnie Thompson has squatted 900lbs raw, Dave Hoff benches over 600lbs raw, Vincient Dizenzo or whatever the spelling is benches 800lbs in a shirt and 600lbs raw in 3 weight classes...

and noone is suggesting bionics, which is a rediculous comparison, maybe lets look at body suits with less wind drag than skin and more advanced shoes/tracks etc

To me thats what makes equipped lifting great and a Sport not just knowing who can win based off gym lifts
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:37 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
MaxCooper said:except people who are stong equipped arent automatically weak raw, infact those who are the stongest in the world EQ. are usually the same guys whod be the stongest uneq.
For example Donnie Thompson has squatted 900lbs raw, Dave Hoff benches over 600lbs raw, Vincient Dizenzo or whatever the spelling is benches 800lbs in a shirt and 600lbs raw in 3 weight classes...

and noone is suggesting bionics, which is a rediculous comparison, maybe lets look at body suits with less wind drag than skin and more advanced shoes/tracks etc

To me thats what makes equipped lifting great and a Sport not just knowing who can win based off gym lifts


What the Classic clearly showed is that lifters get very different amounts out of kit so the best equipped lifters may not be the best raw just as the best multi ply lifters are not necessarily the best if they switch to single ply.

Surely unequipped lifting is the only true test of which lifter is the strongest?
martinbIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:44 
Avatar
Grass fed
Member 1147, 7710 posts
SQ 220, BP 185, DL 272.5
677.5 kgs @ 113kgs UnEq
Steve said:
Surely unequipped lifting is the only true test of which lifter is the strongest?


that seems simple doesn't it?

at the Olympics GB had the best bikes, the best technology, and spent the most money, I don't know that they necessarily had the fastest athletes

personally I would rather see no equipment and everybody riding the same bike
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:44 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Steve said:

Surely unequipped lifting is the only true test of which lifter is the strongest?


Undoubtably. IF people don't mind that then that's fine. Personally I want to be involved in a sterngth sport were the strongest person in class wins.
brownbearIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:49 
Avatar
Morrisons - rump - 7£
Member 2206, 11578 posts
SQ 228, BP 150, DL 260
638.0 kgs @ 98kgs UnEq
MaxCooper said:except people who are stong equipped arent automatically weak raw, infact those who are the stongest in the world EQ. are usually the same guys whod be the stongest uneq.
For example Donnie Thompson has squatted 900lbs raw, Dave Hoff benches over 600lbs raw, Vincient Dizenzo or whatever the spelling is benches 800lbs in a shirt and 600lbs raw in 3 weight classes...

and noone is suggesting bionics, which is a rediculous comparison, maybe lets look at body suits with less wind drag than skin and more advanced shoes/tracks etc

To me thats what makes equipped lifting great and a Sport not just knowing who can win based off gym lifts


Suits that makes you squat 500 lbs more than you ca deadlift are pretty bionic or add 400lbs to your squat or 300 to your bench and pretty bionic!

No shoe will take 2-3s off your 100m time
force10Icon...15-08-2012 @ 13:49 
Avatar
Drugs cheat
Member 3860, 630 posts
SQ 335, BP 210, DL 330
875.0 kgs @ 108kgs UnEq
Steve said:

Surely unequipped lifting is the only true test of which lifter is the strongest?



I totaly agree and think this is the reason unequipped will take over equipped lifting in the future as powerlifting is all about power and strength of that individual lifter not the equipment being used.
brownbearIcon...15-08-2012 @ 13:50 
Avatar
Morrisons - rump - 7£
Member 2206, 11578 posts
SQ 228, BP 150, DL 260
638.0 kgs @ 98kgs UnEq
martinb said:
that seems simple doesn't it?
at the Olympics GB had the best bikes, the best technology, and spent the most money, I don't know that they necessarily had the fastest athletes
personally I would rather see no equipment and everybody riding the same bike


I think I agree with you here
FazcIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:03 
Avatar
Sports an extremely muscular arse.
Member 38, 6253 posts
IainKendrick said:
Strong. As the best guys are in any fed style of powerlifting. However the strongest dosn't always win. Guy whose strong and gets more out of the gear will. This, to me, is the problem with equipped lifting.


Although being strong is a function of technique, whether that's raw or geared. One could argue that equipment is just an extension of that. Just like Roberto Carlos being able to utilise specially made footballs to do what others couldn't do with free kicks. Do we say that was a travesty just because Bobby Charlton and his ilk couldn't do that with the old heavier balls? No, we admire it as it's part of the natural progression of the sport.

Do we condemn modern tennis for not being the 'true' test of sporting skill that it once was when the balls were heavier and the rackets were more unwieldly? No, we admire that as it is also a natural progression of the sport. Am I doing a better job because even though I play down the park I use an old racket?

People have a really unattractive tendency in powerlifting to go down this route of what is 'true strength'. Let's face it, this is nothing new. This is the sport and how it's always been. Lifters have always looked for the edge, this is just a natural extension of that. So what do the 'raw' supporters expect exactly? To change the entire history of the sport, and then they'll be satisfied that somehow it's better?

If you want a different sport then go make yourself a different sport, leave ours alone. We like it.
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:38 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Fazc said:
Although being strong is a function of technique, whether that's raw or geared. One could argue that equipment is just an extension of that. Just like Roberto Carlos being able to utilise specially made footballs to do what others couldn't do with free kicks. Do we say that was a travesty just because Bobby Charlton and his ilk couldn't do that with the old heavier balls? No, we admire it as it's part of the natural progression of the sport.
Do we condemn modern tennis for not being the 'true' test of sporting skill that it once was when the balls were heavier and the rackets were more unwieldly? No, we admire that as it is also a natural progression of the sport. Am I doing a better job because even though I play down the park I use an old racket?
People have a really unattractive tendency in powerlifting to go down this route of what is 'true strength'. Let's face it, this is nothing new. This is the sport and how it's always been. Lifters have always looked for the edge, this is just a natural extension of that. So what do the 'raw' supporters expect exactly? To change the entire history of the sport, and then they'll be satisfied that somehow it's better?
If you want a different sport then go make yourself a different sport, leave ours alone. We like it.


Technique is not clothing. We like it without getting 20% of performance from clothing Happy

No changing history, but we can change were it brought us too. Take whatever supportive equipemnt we use back to an aid to performance not a large % of performance.
FazcIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:46 
Avatar
Sports an extremely muscular arse.
Member 38, 6253 posts
IainKendrick said:No changing history, but we can change were it brought us too. Take whatever supportive equipemnt we use back to an aid to performance not a large % of performance.


So it's not the equipment but how much it adds. A loose Blast shirt would be fine then?

This is what I'm talking about, when you break down the argument for changing the sport to raw it makes no sense. You want support but not too much. What is too much exactly, is there a percentage on that? How do we test that percentage?

Like I said this is the way it's always been. And this is the way progression happens in other sports who rely on equipment. We are no different and this insistence that we should be makes no sense.
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:47 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
martinb said:
that seems simple doesn't it?
at the Olympics GB had the best bikes, the best technology, and spent the most money, I don't know that they necessarily had the fastest athletes
personally I would rather see no equipment and everybody riding the same bike


Better equipment might give a cyclist a tiny edge over their opponents, but when cycles became to extreme didn't the people in charge of cycling ban them so the cyclists are using essentially the same equipment?

Powerlifting equipment completely changes the sport with different techinques and muscles involved.
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:58 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Fazc said:
So it's not the equipment but how much it adds. A loose Blast shirt would be fine then?
This is what I'm talking about, when you break down the argument for changing the sport to raw it makes no sense. You want support but not too much. What is too much exactly, is there a percentage on that? How do we test that percentage?
Like I said this is the way it's always been. And this is the way progression happens in other sports who rely on equipment. We are no different and this insistence that we should be makes no sense.


It's seems perfectly acetable to use some supportive equipment. Wrist wraps, belts something across the knees. This is how the sport started. It was not equipped as you see today. A strength sport should not rely on supportive apparel. That was not the point of powerlifting. Only what it has allowed to become! This can change if people want it to. That is maybe the problem.

You have to draw a line somewhere. This is normal in any sport. If we extend your thinking were do you draw the line on supportive equipment. Are you happy with 50% of performance coming from supportive gear, 80%? Your confusing progress with something that is always positive.
SteveIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:58 
nothing to hide, please follow my life on webcam
Member 255, 3732 posts
Fazc said:
So it's not the equipment but how much it adds. A loose Blast shirt would be fine then?
This is what I'm talking about, when you break down the argument for changing the sport to raw it makes no sense. You want support but not too much. What is too much exactly, is there a percentage on that? How do we test that percentage?
Like I said this is the way it's always been. And this is the way progression happens in other sports who rely on equipment. We are no different and this insistence that we should be makes no sense.


When swim suits became too advanced and were giving the swimmers an advantage they were banned by the governing body. When cars become too fast in F1 the engine sizes were reduced and driver aids banned... - "progress" isn't always a good thing, especially when it changes the sport with different people winning than otherwise would have.
IainKendrickIcon...15-08-2012 @ 14:59 
Avatar
some nice relaxing jazz.
Member 77, 12599 posts
SQ 265, BP 165, DL 280
710.0 kgs @ 93kgs UnEq
Steve said:
Better equipment might give a cyclist a tiny edge over their opponents, but when cycles became to extreme didn't the people in charge of cycling ban them so the cyclists are using essentially the same equipment?
Powerlifting equipment completely changes the sport with different techinques and muscles involved.


Plus at least a bike is an essential requirment in cycling. A bench shirt is not essential to bench pressing.

1234567891011

© Sugden Barbell 2026 Privacy - Terms & Conditions