Twitter Facebook Who's Online - 0 members and 164 guests

Which strongman, PL:er or OL:er would win a street fight without ...

Users viewing topic: & 1 Guest

12345

Draken		Which strongman, PL:er or OL:er would win a street fight without ...	06-07-2017 @ 16:40
I'm daft. Member 6148, 93 posts	Post Edited: 06.07.2017 @ 16:40 PM by Draken ... any rules at all except no biting, no clawing and no scratching. They can stomp eachother et cetera, which is forbidden in UFC (today there's almost this equality sign between UFC and MMA, however that's not the case). And no weight classes. Free for all! The best fighter overall. It's just like an old school MMA fight, with the difference that they fight for their lives, which means that strategy goes right out the window. I'm making a point of this because I don't want any "walk around waiting for the right time to strike, and then someone winning on points. It's just to the death. Raw and brutal. Dead or alive makes no difference, as everyone fights in their prime. Anyways: what do you think, seriously? I think we have to look for Strongmen. OLers aren't strong enough - they are more into power and explosivity than raw, brute strength. PLers train too few events, and lack arms, upper back etc. Most PLers train arms and upper back, yes: but strongmen compete with them. Plus Strongman is more overall than PLing, and they possess higher endurance. I think Brian Shaw would win. He's topping both strength, weight and height. Z isn't tall enough. Perhaps Hafthor could take Shaw - he's taller, but Shaw is heavier (206 vs 200 according to 1st google result). Or perhaps Poundstone! He's "only" 155 kg, meaning he's got more endurance than the rest. While they are struggling, breathing to stay awake, he has some power left. But I don't think he will win. Cyplenkov has a phenomenal grip/hand/arm strength, which can be very effective. However: mr Shaw is too big. Shaw will win ... or maybe Hafthor. Hafthor is younger, taller and probably has more endurance. I would like to see Z or perhaps Koklyaev win, but that won't happen. Who would do best respectively worsT, compared to their placement in Strongman? E g if someone who places 1 in every Strongman contest is a terrible fighter. Best: Pudzianowski or Kazmaier. Why? They are fighters. Wildcard Mikhail Koklyaev. I don't know why. He's not aggressive. But he has that (I imagine) power of being able to struggle on no matter how injured he is. Worst: I hate to say it, but big Z. He's too slow (he lifts to "feel the muscle" rather than as fast as possible) and just does not seem to have "it". He's not aggressive. He's my fav Strongman, but he's no fighter. What do you think?
chubbman		...	06-07-2017 @ 16:51
Another 'hardcore gym'. Yay. Member 4858, 88 posts SQ 120, BP 75, DL 165 360.0 kgs @ 106kgs UnEq	Any of the Russians, russians are crazy
SimonD		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:01
Member 4601, 118 posts	Have to go with Mikhail Shivlyakov he is after all a former Russian marine, those guys are trained to kill at the end of the day and have their own extremely effective martial art Systema, that isn't about scoring points etcetera it's to make sure you are the one that walks out of there alive not your opponent
Wayne_Cowdrey		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:07
Still got a little bit of strength Member 400, 22044 posts	What about a zercher specialist?
scruffmcbuff		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:13
Lovely ass Congrats. Member 5958, 2315 posts SQ 280, BP 170, DL 300 750.0 kgs @ 138kgs UnEq	Kyle Vauls of the GPC.
SimonD		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:13
Member 4601, 118 posts	Wayne_Cowdrey said:What about a zercher specialist? Depends, is it in a phone box?
slimsim		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:16
My asshole is not watertight. Member 2926, 6050 posts SQ 217.5, BP 107.5, DL 225 550.0 kgs @ 86kgs UnEq	My mate in Russia kicks the s**t out of Russian tough guys for fun. And he's a middle-aged man!!!
Wayne_Cowdrey		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:22
Still got a little bit of strength Member 400, 22044 posts	SimonD said: Depends, is it in a phone box? Loal. A phone box with a greasy handle. RAGE!!!
PaulSavage		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:23
Member 2775, 6927 posts	This almost solely depends on who is actually trained to fight / the obvious answer would be either pudz or oli thompson since they are mma fighters now
Wayne_Cowdrey		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:36
Still got a little bit of strength Member 400, 22044 posts	Mentality is a big factor in fighting. How far you're prepared to go and how much you're prepared to take. I'm too much of a softie to want to hurt anybody.
SimonD		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:37
Member 4601, 118 posts	Are we allowing hat throwing, if so Glenn Ross might be one to look out for lol
Wiegieboard		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:52
as crimson as my last victims underclothing..... Member 899, 11329 posts SQ 180, BP 132.5, DL 190 502.5 kgs @ 118kgs UnEq	Current athletes? I have no idea. I'd put money on the most dangerous being an -u120kg athlete though. Maybe even -U105
billynomates		...	06-07-2017 @ 17:55
Member 4923, 1795 posts	Big Sean, all day every day
Mikeneto		...	06-07-2017 @ 18:10
End of an era. Member 4646, 1964 posts	Probably the tall ones...So Shaw and Thor. I guess Terry Holland's would be good...big and wasn't he good at Judo?
Funky_monkey		...	06-07-2017 @ 18:17
403 forbidden message Member 160, 5121 posts SQ 190, BP 137.5, DL 225 552.5 kgs @ 86kgs UnEq	I think Hall could take a fight if it was under a minute long and he just killed the guy. Dave Beattie but he has a s**t reach. Ex marine and I've experienced a few of his "friendly" slaps. Otherwise, Pudz.

12345